Desserts to Take
No time to mix, make, blend and bake? No problem! We offer an assortment of fresh-baked treats and goodies that are perfect for any holiday get-together.
Visit our bakery to explore the possibilities. Bonus: Our pies and cakes are crafted with the finest ingredients, and they taste just as delicious as any homemade classic. (Don’t worry, it’ll be our little secret.)
Move Over Pie, Make Room for Cheesecake & Cake
New! Seasonal Cheesecakes Our new lusciously rich cheesecakes embody decadent flavors that are perfect for Thanksgiving. Our Hot Buttered Rum Cheesecake is sweetly spiced and full of butter vanilla flavor. Our Hot Cocoa Cheesecake takes everything you relish in a hot mug and transforms it into a delicious creamy cake with a chocolate cookie crust. Indulgence is the only option.
New! Seasonal Cakes While pies will always have a seat at the holiday table, this year, welcome our new seasonal cakes to your dessert lineup. These craveable confections are filled with decadent layers of creamy mousse, spongy cake and enticing fillings–a memorable finish to your holiday meal. Choose from delicious options like Dark Chocolate Pumpkin Cake, Browned Butter Pecan Cake, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cake, Irish Cream Cake or Italian Rum Cake.
Baked by Popular Demand
Make your holiday dessert as easy as pie - or a piece of cake - with these festive favorites. Our pre-made pies and cakes are sure to delight everyone at your table, from chocolate-lovers to pumpkin spice enthusiasts. We brought back these seasonal treats to our bakery for you to enjoy.
No dessert table is complete without a perfectly-spiced pumpkin pie. This classic, baked-in-store treat is crafted with flavorful ingredients like real pumpkin and autumn spices. Cook Like A Chef >> Tip from Chef Jarrod: Break out that brûlée torch that you’ve only used once and torch a generous portion of granulated sugar over your pie before serving.
Whether you say “pee-can” or “pah-cahn,” one thing is certain: Pecan Pie is a must-have during the holidays. A decadent blend of brown sugar, syrup, eggs and crunchy pecans gives this Southern classic its irresistibly ooey-gooey texture and signature flavor. We also have a chocolate recipe with chunks of chocolate fudge!
Our apple pie starts with a light, flaky, handcrafted crust. The filling features a generous amount of fresh Ida Red apples grown in New York State, with just enough cinnamon sugar to sweeten every bite.
This luscious pie features rich, buttery filling studded with chocolate chips and English walnuts. If you really want to go all out, try serving our chocolate walnut pie warm with a generous scoop of creamy vanilla ice cream.
Chocolate-lovers, rejoice. This delicious cake has three layers of chocolate fudge and chocolate cake, topped with rich chocolate icing and creamy chocolate ganache.
Made with Chantilly cream and strawberry jam, this moist white cake is topped with fresh strawberries from our Produce Department.
Family Size Desserts & Cheesecakes
Feeding a crowd? We offer a wide array of desserts to accommodate your friends and family.
We have a flavorful Tiramisu Layer Cake, along with a variety of whole New York-style cheesecakes.
Choose from Plain Cheesecake, Brownie Cheesecake topped with brownie chunks and rich chocolate sauce and Italian-style Ricotta Cheesecake with shortbread crust.