Desserts to Take
No time to mix, make, blend and bake? No problem! We offer an assortment of fresh-baked treats and goodies that are perfect for any holiday get-together.
Visit our bakery to explore the possibilities. Bonus: Our pies and cakes are crafted with the finest ingredients, and they taste just as delicious as any homemade classic. (Don’t worry, it’ll be our little secret.)
Take the Cake
Have your cake and eat it, too! No baking required. Our cakes are equal parts stunning and delectable. For our newest cakes, we sampled more than 200 recipes before landing on a handful of confections that stood apart from the rest. Taste the difference for yourself!
Our new offerings are rich, flavorful and impressive enough for any holiday dessert table. Pineapple Brown Sugar Cake is one of our favorites. It’s made with a generous amount of juicy, sweet pineapple, along with pineapple brown sugar mousse and decadent brown sugar streusel.
We also have Boston Cream Cake made with rich custard, yellow cake and chocolate ganache, along with super-decadent Triple Chocolate Truffle Cake. For elevated classics, try Carrot or Red Velvet Cake (colored naturally with beets!).
Baked by Popular Demand
These cakes are so delicious, we brought them back to our bakery for you to enjoy.
1Chocolate Ganache Cake
Chocolate-lovers, rejoice. This double layer chocolate cake is finished with chocolate cream cheese icing, chocolate shavings and a drizzle of chocolate sauce. It’s super-decadent, deliciously indulgent and sure to delight anyone with a sweet tooth!
2Strawberry Chantilly Cake
Made with Chantilly cream and strawberry jam, this moist white cake is topped with fresh strawberries from our Produce Department.
3White Chocolate Cranberry Cake
Available for a limited time, this decadent white cake features white chocolate ganache and a layer of cranberry filling.
Make your holiday dessert as easy as pie with these festive favorites. Our pre-made pies are sure to delight everyone at your table, from chocolate-lovers to pumpkin spice enthusiasts. The dough is made in small batches to ensure a flaky crust and filled with everything from fresh Ida Red apples and cinnamon sugar to rich, creamy butter and crunchy pecans.
To make things even sweeter, a portion of proceeds from every cream pie sold during the month of November will go to our partner Feeding America. Every dollar raised helps provide at least 10 meals to people in need.
We’ve taken our classic pies to the next level with real whipped cream and sweet toppings like chocolate chips, seasonal cookies and premium chocolate shavings. Try Deluxe Chocolate Pecan Pie, Deluxe Pecan Pie, Deluxe Pumpkin Pie and Deluxe Sweet Potato Pie.
Made with real whipped cream, our cream pies are decorated and finished by hand. Each one has a perfectly flaky crust that complements the rich cream filling, which is whipped until it’s light and fluffy. Choose from Pumpkin Praline Cream Pie, French Chocolate Silk Cream Pie, Chocolate Silk Peanut Butter Cream Pie and Bananas Foster Cream Pie.
3Elegant Farmer Caramel Apple Pie & Elegant Farmer Apple Blueberry Pie
Traditionally baked in brown paper bags, Elegant Farmer Pies have a crunchy, sugar cookie-like top crust and a light, flaky bottom crust. They’ve been praised as the “best pie in America” by The Wall Street Journal, Gourmet magazine, Food Network and others—for good reason!
Add a rustic touch to any holiday spread with our hand-pleated Colonial Apple Pie. The tender, flaky crust is loaded with fresh Ida Red apples, sprinkled with cinnamon sugar and baked in-store. Weighing in at four pounds, it’s a veritable feast for the senses!
Who doesn’t love a delicious apple crisp? Savor the flavors of the season with an irresistible blend of fresh, sweet apples and fragrant spices. Each crisp is finished off with a rich brown sugar crumb topping. We recommend serving this dessert warm with a scoop of your favorite vanilla ice cream.
6Old Fashioned Apple
This classic pie starts with an old-fashioned, hand-crafted crust that’s light and flaky. Each pie is packed full of fresh Ida Red Apples grown in New York State, along with just enough sugar and cinnamon to accentuate the fresh apple flavor.
There are so many wonderful ways to enjoy sweet potatoes, and Sweet Potato Pie is one of the best. Baked with tasty ingredients, this smooth, seasonal sensation won’t last long! For extra flavor, try this simple recipe for Cinnamon Whipped Cream. Cinnamon and sweet potatoes go together like peanut butter and jelly, or two back-to-back slices of pie.
No dessert table is complete without a perfectly-spiced pumpkin pie. This classic, baked-in-store treat is crafted with flavorful ingredients like real pumpkin and autumn spices. For a little extra oomph, try this simple recipe for Cinnamon Whipped Cream. The rich flavor and creamy texture makes our pie simply irresistible.
Whether you say “pee-can” or “pah-cahn,” one thing is certain: Pecan Pie is a must-have during the holidays. A decadent blend of brown sugar, syrup, eggs and crunchy pecans gives this Southern classic its irresistibly ooey-gooey texture and signature flavor. If you really want to go all out, try serving our Pecan Pie warm with a generous scoop of creamy vanilla ice cream.
Calling all chocolate-lovers: Our Chocolate Fudge Pie is exquisitely rich and undeniably delicious! Made in the style of a classic chocolate chess pie, the filling is smooth and decadent with deep chocolate flavor. Although this pie stands out on its own, you can also top it with fresh whipped cream for a satisfying contrast of flavors and textures.
11Chocolate Pecan Pie
Our chocolate pecan pie is made with a buttery, flaky crust, fresh pecans and classic Southern-inspired ingredients. We’ve added creamy chocolate chips for even more rich flavor you’ll love.
Family Size Desserts & Cheesecakes
Feeding a crowd? We offer a wide array of desserts to accommodate your friends and family, from large fruit tarts to luscious cheesecakes.
Made with a generous amount of fresh fruit from our Produce Department, our Large Rectangular Signature Fruit Tart serves 8-10 guests.
We also have a flavorful Tiramisu Layer Cake, along with a variety of whole New York-style cheesecakes.
Choose from Plain Cheesecake, Apple Pie Cheesecake, Brownie Cheesecake topped with brownie chunks and rich chocolate sauce, Italian-style Ricotta Cheesecake with shortbread crust, and Raspberry White Chocolate Cheesecake with a swirl of raspberry filling.